Stillwater Bay Homes for Sale

Stillwater Bay is a Lake Hartwell neighborhood where the shoreline defines the address. Most homes sit on waterfront parcels or near the waterline, and the strongest properties pair deep-water cove access with covered docks, boat lifts, and broad lake views. Pricing runs from the mid-$300,000s into seven figures on the strongest waterfront parcels, while lots themselves stretch from roughly an acre to 2.75 acres with shade trees and natural buffers.

Community Highlights

The housing stock is mixed rather than repetitive. Brick appears on some homes, while other properties lean into log construction and other lake-home finishes. What stays consistent is the way the homes are laid out: hardwood floors, fireplaces, granite kitchens, main-level primary suites, and outdoor living spaces that open toward the lake. Finished basements are a major part of the neighborhood character, often adding separate living areas, kitchenette or wet-bar space, workshops, storage, and exterior access. Garages are also standard, with some homes offering oversized attached space and others adding detached parking or basement-level garages.