Treasure Bay Homes for Sale

Community Highlights

Treasure Bay sits on the Fair Play side of Lake Hartwell, and the neighborhood''s strongest draw is straightforward: large homesites, direct waterfront options, and quick access to the water. Current opportunities range from roughly 0.60 to 1.16 acres, while built homes in the subdivision have recently traded from about $145,000 to $655,000, with a pending lakefront offering at $875,000.

Most built homes cluster along Bay Drive and were constructed between 2005 and 2023. The earlier lakefront houses pair generous lots with concrete or golf-cart-friendly paths to private covered docks, while the newest deliveries bring wooded settings, front porches, covered patios, bonus rooms, and main-level primary suites. Oversized garages are a recurring theme here, including attached bays sized for boats, workshops, and extra storage, and basements appear regularly in the neighborhood''s listing history.

Amenities & Lifestyle

Treasure Bay does not center on a clubhouse or pool complex; its day-to-day appeal is tied to Lake Hartwell itself. Several homes offer private shoreline, covered slip docks, double-slip setups, or decks and screened porches aimed directly at the water. Even the interior homesites are marketed around fast access to boating, with Glenn Ferry and Durham boat ramps a short drive away.

Outdoor living carries as much weight as the interiors. Wraparound porches, covered back porches, lakeside decks, mature trees, and wooded backdrops show up throughout the subdivision. Inside, the most common layouts favor open living areas, formal dining rooms or breakfast spaces, stone fireplaces, and flexible lower levels that can absorb storage, guest space, office use, or future expansion.