Skip to main content

Settlers Grove Homes for Sale in Salisbury, SC

Settlers Grove has the feel of a newer Salisbury neighborhood that was built for space, light, and everyday ease.

Active
1
Recently Sold
48+

Active & Pending Listings

About Settlers Grove

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Settlers Grove, Salisbury

First Impressions

Settlers Grove has the feel of a newer Salisbury neighborhood that was built for space, light, and everyday ease. Homes here generally date from the late 2000s through 2020, and the streets are lined with single-family residences that make the most of open interiors, generous rooms, and practical layouts. Many homes feature front-loaded garages, and the neighborhood’s lot sizes give each property a little breathing room without losing the sense of a connected community.

"Settlers Grove pairs newer construction with a calm, lived-in suburban rhythm just outside the city limits."

Home Styles & Community Feel

The architecture leans modern and comfortable rather than formal. Expect two-story plans, ranch layouts, and flexible designs with lofts, bonus rooms, or main-level primary suites. Inside, the recurring themes are bright kitchens, open-concept living areas, gas fireplaces, quartz or granite surfaces, and covered or screened outdoor spaces. Several homes also highlight fenced backyards, patios, porches, and substantial storage. The overall impression is of a neighborhood that values function as much as presentation, with homes that are easy to live in and easy to personalize.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Settlers Grove does not read like a place built around resort-style extras; instead, its appeal comes from the way the homes and setting support an uncomplicated routine. Sidewalks and mature trees appear in the neighborhood descriptions, and the one-street, dead-end feel mentioned in remarks suggests a more contained residential setting. The strongest amenity is the home itself: attached garages, roomy kitchens, flexible loft spaces, and outdoor areas that extend daily living beyond the main interior. With no basements, no waterfront, and no pool pattern to anchor the community, the emphasis stays on usable square footage and private yard space.

"This is a neighborhood for buyers who want newer homes, practical layouts, and quick access to the city’s main routes."

Location & Schools

Settlers Grove sits just outside the Salisbury city limits, with frequent references to I-85 and downtown Salisbury. One listing notes the neighborhood is about 2 minutes from I-85, while another places downtown Salisbury about 5 minutes away. The community is also described as less than 5 minutes from I-85 and shopping, which makes day-to-day errands straightforward. The school pattern is consistent as well: Elizabeth Koontz Elementary, Southeast Middle, and Jesse Carson High are the commonly cited schools, placing the neighborhood in a familiar Salisbury feeder pattern. For buyers who want a residential setting with quick highway access and a direct line into town, Settlers Grove is well positioned.

Questions about Settlers Grove?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Salisbury

Ask about Settlers Grove — we answer fast

Own a home in Settlers Grove?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Settlers Grove sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Settlers Grove

Recently Sold in Settlers Grove Showing 1-48+ recently sold in Settlers Grove, Salisbury with dates and property details ↓

Recently Sold

Showing 1-48+ recently sold in Settlers Grove, Salisbury

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
509 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 509 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 3 ba Jun 9 2026 $392,000 358 2,711 sq ft 95.6% $145
555 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 555 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba May 21 2026 $395,000 80 3,099 sq ft 100.0% $127
312 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 312 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 30 2025 $350,000 96 1,881 sq ft 94.9% $186
541 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 541 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba May 15 2025 $330,000 52 1,749 sq ft 100.0% $189
184 Settlers Grove Lane L7 sold home in Salisbury, SC 184 Settlers Grove Lane L7 4 bd · 2 ba May 1 2025 $415,000 72 2,847 sq ft 100.0% $146
303 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 303 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Mar 3 2025 $362,000 125 1,747 sq ft 99.2% $207
300 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 300 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba May 13 2024 $350,000 167 1,704 sq ft 101.5% $205
184 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 184 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba May 6 2024 $390,000 115 2,772 sq ft 98.1% $141
484 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 484 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 23 2022 $365,000 38 2,144 sq ft 98.6% $170
303 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 303 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 16 2022 $345,000 27 1,739 sq ft 107.8% $198
315 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 315 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba May 17 2022 $355,000 40 1,798 sq ft 100.0% $197
184 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 184 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Apr 26 2022 $400,000 25 2,896 sq ft 106.7% $138
274 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 274 Settlers Grove Lane 5 bd · 2 ba Sep 9 2021 $320,000 49 3,179 sq ft 103.2% $101
541 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 541 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 13 2021 $271,500 35 1,535 sq ft 98.7% $177
355 Settlers Grove Lane 59 sold home in Salisbury, SC 355 Settlers Grove Lane 59 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 30 2020 $207,205 490 1,801 sq ft 100.5% $115
312 Settlers Grove Lane 17 sold home in Salisbury, SC 312 Settlers Grove Lane 17 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 21 2020 $218,880 141 1,801 sq ft 98.2% $122
484 Settlers Grove Lane 30 sold home in Salisbury, SC 484 Settlers Grove Lane 30 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 20 2020 $237,230 142 2,144 sq ft 99.7% $111
300 Settlers Grove Lane 16 sold home in Salisbury, SC 300 Settlers Grove Lane 16 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 3 2020 $224,800 122 1,725 sq ft 100.0% $130
400 Settlers Grove Lane 24 sold home in Salisbury, SC 400 Settlers Grove Lane 24 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 23 2020 $209,915 189 1,801 sq ft 98.1% $117
540 Settlers Grove Lane 33 sold home in Salisbury, SC 540 Settlers Grove Lane 33 3 bd · 2 ba May 11 2020 $210,330 146 1,725 sq ft 98.1% $122
569 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 569 Settlers Grove Lane 5 bd · 3 ba Apr 24 2020 $264,900 50 2,883 sq ft 100.0% $92
381 Settlers Grove Lane 57 sold home in Salisbury, SC 381 Settlers Grove Lane 57 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 31 2020 $232,155 105 2,234 sq ft 98.3% $104
374 Settlers Grove Lane 22 sold home in Salisbury, SC 374 Settlers Grove Lane 22 3 bd · 2 ba Feb 28 2020 $234,395 142 2,144 sq ft 100.1% $109
265 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 265 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 22 2019 $230,250 143 2,279 sq ft 97.1% $101
405 Settlers Grove Lane 55 sold home in Salisbury, SC 405 Settlers Grove Lane 55 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 14 2019 $217,485 131 1,725 sq ft 100.0% $126
279 Settlers Grove Lane 65 sold home in Salisbury, SC 279 Settlers Grove Lane 65 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 7 2019 $209,965 97 1,725 sq ft 100.4% $122
253 Settlers Grove Lane 67 sold home in Salisbury, SC 253 Settlers Grove Lane 67 4 bd · 2 ba Sep 25 2019 $226,255 91 2,234 sq ft 99.9% $101
329 Settlers Grove Lane 61 sold home in Salisbury, SC 329 Settlers Grove Lane 61 3 bd · 2 ba Sep 17 2019 $216,840 77 1,725 sq ft 103.4% $126
248 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 248 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 31 2019 $232,000 153 2,144 sq ft 100.0% $108
509 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 509 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 3 ba Jul 25 2019 $259,000 86 2,582 sq ft 100.0% $100
149 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 149 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 19 2019 $212,175 141 1,801 sq ft 102.0% $118
239 Settlers Grove Lane 68 sold home in Salisbury, SC 239 Settlers Grove Lane 68 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 19 2019 $226,785 141 1,725 sq ft 109.0% $131
215 Settlers Grove Lane 70 sold home in Salisbury, SC 215 Settlers Grove Lane 70 4 bd · 2 ba Apr 27 2018 $195,000 39 2,173 sq ft 94.2% $90
215 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 215 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Apr 27 2018 $195,000 39 2,173 sq ft 94.2% $90
222 Settlers Grove Lane 10 sold home in Salisbury, SC 222 Settlers Grove Lane 10 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 28 2018 $179,990 449 2,805 sq ft 100.0% $64
630 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 630 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Aug 17 2017 $210,000 128 3,047 sq ft 106.3% $69
291 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 291 Settlers Grove Lane 5 bd · 2 ba Jul 31 2017 $244,900 52 3,063 sq ft 100.0% $80
541 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 541 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 5 2017 $166,000 41 1,535 sq ft 100.7% $108
541 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 541 Settlers Grove Lane 3 bd · 2 ba Jun 5 2017 $166,000 41 1,535 sq ft 100.7% $108
569 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 569 Settlers Grove Lane 5 bd · 3 ba May 26 2017 $219,500 113 2,883 sq ft 95.5% $76
184 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 184 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 31 2017 $219,000 58 2,832 sq ft 99.6% $77
184 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 184 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 31 2017 $219,000 58 2,832 sq ft 99.6% $77
L10 222 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC L10 222 Settlers Grove Lane Dec 8 2016 $19,000 314 — 95.5% —
163 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 163 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Jul 15 2015 $185,500 49 2,148 sq ft 97.7% $86
163 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 163 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Jul 15 2015 $185,500 49 2,148 sq ft 97.7% $86
274 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 274 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 28 2014 $217,900 255 3,133 sq ft 96.9% $70
274 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 274 Settlers Grove Lane 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 28 2014 $217,900 255 3,020 sq ft 96.9% $72
175 Settlers Grove Lane sold home in Salisbury, SC 175 Settlers Grove Lane 5 bd · 3 ba Jul 12 2013 $222,000 268 2,824 sq ft 96.6% $79

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Settlers Grove, Salisbury

Median sale price · trailing 12 mo
$355,000
5 sales closed · Sep 2021 – Aug 2022
Salisbury 1 yr ▴ 10.8%

Settlers Grove median sale price is $355,000; Salisbury is up 10.8%.

Below trend-line threshold — city median shown for context

$200k $250k $300k $350k $400k 20222023202420252026 $305k Salisbury Sales closed per quarter peak 3

The Settlers Grove real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 115 days. With 1 active listing and 3 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price
$369,900
Average Price
$369,900
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$99
1-Yr Price Trend
+8.3%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
3.6
Avg Bathrooms
2.1
Avg Lot Size
0.33 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
1
Sold Last Year
3
Median Days to Sell
115 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
2013
New Construction
0%

Recently Off Market Properties

Listings taken off the market in the past year in Settlers Grove, Salisbury

1 property
Looking for similar properties?

These homes are no longer available, but they show recent pricing and listing activity in Settlers Grove. Our agents can help you watch for new listings in this area.

Contact an agent
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.