Gilbertown Homes for Sale
2 homesCommunity Highlights
- Generous lot sizes
- Custom homes with flexible floor plans
- Close access to downtown Rutherfordton and regional trails
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Rails to Trails · Thermal Belt Rail Trail
Rutherford Regional Medical Center
Rutherford County Airport · Hwy 221 · Hwy 64 +1
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Architecture & Style
- Vaulted Ceilings
- Granite Countertops
- Fireplaces
- Bonus Rooms
- Finished Basements
- Decks
- Screened Porches
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Location & Proximity
Foothills region, western North Carolina
- Downtown Rutherfordton
- Rails to Trails
- Thermal Belt Rail Trail
- Rutherford Regional Medical Center
- Rutherford County Airport
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Lots and Land in Gilbertown
First Impressions
Gilbertown in Rutherfordton has the feel of an established foothills address where larger lots, mature trees, and custom-built homes create a distinctly spacious setting. The neighborhood’s setting leans rural without feeling remote, and many properties are tucked onto generous acreage that gives each home room to breathe. Recent listings show a mix of substantial residences, workshops, decks, and finished lower levels, reinforcing the sense that this is a place where homes are designed to be used fully, inside and out.
"Spacious lots and custom homes give Gilbertown its refined country character."
Home Styles & Community Feel
Most homes here are single-family residences built from the late 1990s through the 2000s, with a strong emphasis on custom layouts and practical extras. Vaulted ceilings, granite kitchens, fireplaces, bonus rooms, sunrooms, screened porches, and finished basements appear often enough to feel characteristic rather than incidental. Garage parking is common, and several homes also add detached workshops, extra storage, or flexible outbuildings that expand the usable footprint beyond the main house. Lot sizes tend to be notably generous, and the overall impression is of a neighborhood that values privacy, craftsmanship, and space for hobbies or multi-use living.
These insights are based on listing details and are informational only; verify details for any specific property.
Market Trends
Buyers have more negotiating power. Properties may take longer to sell. Prices have increased 1106%. There's typically room for negotiation on price.
Year-over-Year Comparison
Last 12 months





Recently Sold Properties
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() SOLD 126 Ransom Way 5 bed4 bath | Apr 24 2026 | $542,500 | 39 | 97% | 3640 sq ft | $149 |
![]() SOLD 523 Shepherds Creek Circle 4 bed2 bath | Mar 25 2026 | $295,000 | 33 | 92% | 2116 sq ft | $139 |
![]() SOLD 0 Shepherds Creek Circle Lot 5 | Feb 9 2026 | $27,500 | 248 | 73% | — | — |
![]() SOLD 196 Col Hamptons Court 3 bed3 bath | Feb 3 2026 | $570,000 | 232 | 95% | 4022 sq ft | $142 |
6 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 0 Pumkin Patch None | Jul 31 2025 | $45,000 | 314 | 73% | — | — |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD Lot 33 Shepherds Creek Circle | May 7 2025 | $18,000 | 308 | 90% | — | — |
![]() SOLD 147 Pumkin Patch Road 4 bed5 bath | Mar 21 2025 | $1.10M | 275 | 92% | 7163 sq ft | $154 |
6 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 183 Pumkin Patch Road 4 bed5 bath | Sep 10 2024 | $625,000 | 74 | 93% | 3637 sq ft | $172 |
1+ year gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 0 Pumkin Patch Road | Jul 17 2023 | $35,000 | 284 | 78% | — | — |
9 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 145 Major Fergusons Hill 3 bed2 bath | Sep 29 2022 | $319,500 | 144 | 98% | 1921 sq ft | $166 |
![]() SOLD 0 Shepherds Creek Circle | Sep 28 2022 | $43,000 | 30 | 🎯100% | — | — |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 109 Col Hamptons Court 3 bed3 bath | Jul 8 2022 | $420,000 | 53 | 91% | 3382 sq ft | $124 |
![]() SOLD 194 Turkey Roost Drive 3 bed2 bath | Jul 1 2022 | $520,000 | 81 | 87% | 3591 sq ft | $145 |
![]() SOLD 207 Pumkin Patch Road 3 bed2 bath | May 16 2022 | $500,000 | 49 | 🎯100% | 2360 sq ft | $212 |
![]() SOLD 183 Pumpkin Patch Road 4 bed5 bath | May 6 2022 | $515,000 | 78 | 🎯103% | 3637 sq ft | $142 |
![]() SOLD 102 Major Fergusons Hill 4 bed3 bath | Apr 8 2022 | $440,000 | 126 | 99% | 2565 sq ft | $172 |
![]() SOLD 146 Major Fergusons Street 5 bed4 bath | Mar 21 2022 | $455,000 | 221 | 91% | 3576 sq ft | $127 |
![]() SOLD Lot 105 Turkey Roost Road | Feb 25 2022 | $30,000 | 147 | 61% | — | — |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 0 Pumkin Patch Street | Oct 27 2021 | $20,000 | 37 | 🎯105% | — | — |
7 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 189 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Mar 12 2021 | $300,000 | 62 | 🎯102% | 2159 sq ft | $139 |
![]() SOLD 539 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Feb 9 2021 | $405,000 | 32 | 🎯100% | 2378 sq ft | $170 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 196 Col Hamptons Court 3 bed3 bath | Dec 2 2020 | $425,000 | 107 | 95% | 4103 sq ft | $104 |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 146 Pumkin Patch Road 3 bed3 bath | Jul 21 2020 | $440,000 | 76 | 96% | 4904 sq ft | $90 |
5 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 640 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Feb 19 2020 | $314,000 | 107 | 97% | 2118 sq ft | $148 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 126 Ransom Way 4 bed4 bath | Dec 13 2019 | $361,250 | 269 | 96% | 3640 sq ft | $99 |
11 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 109 Col Hamptons Court 3 bed3 bath | Dec 28 2018 | $269,000 | 178 | 🎯100% | 3382 sq ft | $80 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 189 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Oct 12 2018 | $245,000 | 191 | 98% | 2123 sq ft | $115 |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 397 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Jun 12 2018 | $275,000 | 64 | 🎯100% | 2222 sq ft | $124 |
![]() SOLD 194 Turkey Roost None 3 bed2 bath | May 22 2018 | $347,000 | 63 | 99% | 3586 sq ft | $97 |
5 month gap in market activity | ||||||
![]() SOLD 640 Shepherds Creek Circle 3 bed2 bath | Nov 27 2017 | $293,000 | 83 | 98% | 2118 sq ft | $138 |

126 Ransom Way
$542,500

523 Shepherds Creek Circle
$295,000

0 Shepherds Creek Circle Lot 5
$27,500

196 Col Hamptons Court
$570,000

0 Pumkin Patch None
$45,000

Lot 33 Shepherds Creek Circle
$18,000

147 Pumkin Patch Road
$1,100,000

183 Pumkin Patch Road
$625,000

0 Pumkin Patch Road
$35,000

145 Major Fergusons Hill
$319,500

0 Shepherds Creek Circle
$43,000

109 Col Hamptons Court
$420,000

194 Turkey Roost Drive
$520,000

207 Pumkin Patch Road
$500,000

183 Pumpkin Patch Road
$515,000

102 Major Fergusons Hill
$440,000

146 Major Fergusons Street
$455,000

Lot 105 Turkey Roost Road
$30,000

0 Pumkin Patch Street
$20,000

189 Shepherds Creek Circle
$300,000

539 Shepherds Creek Circle
$405,000

196 Col Hamptons Court
$425,000

146 Pumkin Patch Road
$440,000

640 Shepherds Creek Circle
$314,000

126 Ransom Way
$361,250

109 Col Hamptons Court
$269,000

189 Shepherds Creek Circle
$245,000

397 Shepherds Creek Circle
$275,000

194 Turkey Roost None
$347,000

640 Shepherds Creek Circle
$293,000
Market Statistics
The Gilbertown real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 90 days. With 2 active listings and 5 homes sold in the past year, Buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Pricing
Median Price:$707,500
Average Price:$707,500
Property Details
Avg Bedrooms:3.4
Avg Bathrooms:2.8
Avg Lot Size:1.63 acres
Market Activity
Active Listings:2
Sold Last Year:5
Median Days to Sell:90 days
Community Info
Median Year Built:2003
New Construction:0%
Recently Off Market Properties
1 propertyLooking for similar properties?
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in Gilbertown. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.















