Edgewater Homes Near Fishing Creek Lake
49 homesmaster planned
Community Highlights
- 18-hole public golf course integrated into the neighborhood
- Marina, docks, and boat storage tied to Fishing Creek Lake access
- Large concentration of 2017-2025 construction across multiple sections
- Mix of waterfront, golf-street, and low-maintenance cottage settings
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Championship
Event Space · Restaurant · Billiards Room +1
Clubhouse Access
Walking · Biking · Lakeside Segments
Playground · Lakeside Pavilion · Fire Pits +1
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Architecture & Style
- Open Floor Plans
- Bonus Rooms Or Lofts
- Screened Porches
- Walk In Closets
- Kitchen Islands
- Granite Or Quartz Counters
- Stainless Appliances
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Location & Proximity
Lake-oriented section of Lancaster County
- Fishing Creek Lake
- Brickwood Restaurant
- Lancaster shopping and medical services
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Nearby Schools
Erwin
South Middle
Lancaster
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Lots and Land in Edgewater
Edgewater brings together two amenities that rarely show up at this scale in Lancaster: direct access to Fishing Creek Lake and an 18-hole public golf course woven through the neighborhood.
Community Highlights
Edgewater brings together two amenities that rarely show up at this scale in Lancaster: direct access to Fishing Creek Lake and an 18-hole public golf course woven through the neighborhood. The result is a master-planned community where waterfront homes, interior golf-street homes, and low-maintenance cottage sections all sit under the same resort-oriented umbrella. Recent construction is a major part of the story here, with many homes built from 2017 through 2025 and premium closed-sale streets such as Harbor Watch Court, Arnold Palmer Circle, and Greg Norman Drive pushing well above the community's overall average.
Most homes are detached single-family residences, and the housing mix leans heavily toward open layouts with large kitchen islands, screened porches, bonus rooms or lofts, walk-in closets, and attached garages. Main-level primary suites appear regularly, especially in the cottage and ranch-style plans, while larger two-story homes add recreation rooms, guest suites, and three-car garages. Exterior descriptions are mixed rather than uniform, with siding and occasional brick accents appearing across listings rather than a single dominant material.
Amenities & Lifestyle
Edgewater's amenity package is unusually broad for the price point. Residents have recurring access to two pools, tennis and pickleball courts, walking and biking trails, a lakeside pavilion, playground space, fishing ponds, and a marina with boat storage, docks, and launch access. Golf remains the headline feature: agents repeatedly highlight the nationally ranked public 18-hole course, putting green, and electronic driving range, and several newer sections are named for major golf figures, reinforcing the identity of the neighborhood.
Water is more than background scenery here. Lake views, waterfront lots, pond frontage, wooded backdrops, and cul-de-sac settings are all part of the mix, and screened outdoor living areas show up again and again because they make the most of the setting. Brickwood restaurant and clubhouse spaces add a social hub inside the community without making daily errands feel disconnected from Lancaster.
These insights are based on listing details and are informational only; verify details for any specific property.
Market Trends
Buyers have more negotiating power. Properties may take longer to sell. Prices have increased 27%.
Year-over-Year Comparison
Last 12 months
Recently Sold Properties
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 SOLD 12001 Sam Snead Court 3 bed2 bath | Apr 29 2026 | $419,999 | 41 | 🎯100% | 2321 sq ft | $181 |
 SOLD 50139 Robins Nest Lane 2 bed2 bath | Apr 28 2026 | $265,000 | 54 | 91% | 1656 sq ft | $160 |
 SOLD 13125 Arnold Palmer Circle 3 bed3 bath | Apr 15 2026 | $673,990 | 191 | 🎯100% | 3555 sq ft | $190 |
 SOLD 40117 Crooked Stick Drive 3 bed2 bath | Apr 14 2026 | $292,000 | 125 | 96% | 1681 sq ft | $174 |
 SOLD 9465 Tradewinds Court 4 bed3 bath | Apr 13 2026 | $735,000 | 44 | 🎯100% | 2929 sq ft | $251 |
 SOLD 21260 Sanctuary Drive 3 bed3 bath | Mar 31 2026 | $365,000 | 31 | 99% | 2011 sq ft | $182 |
 SOLD 4642 Monterrico Drive 3 bed2 bath | Mar 31 2026 | $443,151 | 13 | 🎯100% | 2318 sq ft | $191 |
 SOLD 4612 Monterrico Drive 3 bed2 bath | Mar 31 2026 | $510,000 | 26 | 🎯100% | 2485 sq ft | $205 |
 SOLD 70147 Calcutta Lane 3 bed2 bath | Mar 31 2026 | $282,895 | 212 | 🎯100% | 1140 sq ft | $248 |
 SOLD 4630 Monterrico Drive 4 bed3 bath | Mar 31 2026 | $567,606 | 19 | 🎯100% | 3649 sq ft | $156 |
 SOLD 25968 Appleyard Court 3 bed3 bath | Mar 25 2026 | $354,900 | 195 | 🎯100% | 1980 sq ft | $179 |
 SOLD 26043 Appleyard Court 3 bed3 bath | Mar 25 2026 | $290,000 | 203 | 97% | 1634 sq ft | $177 |
 SOLD 11058 Argosy Drive 4 bed2 bath | Mar 17 2026 | $340,000 | 151 | 🎯113% | 2248 sq ft | $151 |
 SOLD 40199 Crooked Stick Drive 3 bed2 bath | Mar 17 2026 | $359,000 | 250 | 🎯100% | 1899 sq ft | $189 |
 SOLD 5299 Admirals Landing 3 bed3 bath | Mar 16 2026 | $475,000 | 62 | 🎯100% | 2307 sq ft | $206 |
 SOLD 24604 Blue Heron Circle 2 bed2 bath | Feb 25 2026 | $265,000 | 197 | 96% | 1815 sq ft | $146 |
 SOLD 10339 Lakeshore Drive 85 3 bed2 bath | Feb 19 2026 | $350,000 | 255 | 99% | 1626 sq ft | $215 |
 SOLD 13038 Arnold Palmer Circle 1053 4 bed3 bath | Feb 12 2026 | $580,000 | 73 | 99% | 3301 sq ft | $176 |
 SOLD 24613 Blue Heron Circle 432 3 bed2 bath | Feb 9 2026 | $349,900 | 126 | 🎯100% | 1899 sq ft | $184 |
 SOLD 44010 Donald Ross Court 1028 3 bed3 bath | Feb 6 2026 | $435,000 | 67 | 98% | 3082 sq ft | $141 |
 SOLD 10315 Lakeshore Drive 89 5 bed3 bath | Feb 6 2026 | $559,000 | 67 | 🎯100% | 3663 sq ft | $153 |
 SOLD 13032 Arnold Palmer Circle 1052 4 bed3 bath | Feb 4 2026 | $519,400 | 146 | 🎯100% | 3193 sq ft | $163 |
 SOLD 5220 Admirals Landing 3 bed2 bath | Jan 28 2026 | $337,000 | 90 | 99% | 1866 sq ft | $181 |
 SOLD 10423 Lakeshore Drive 71 3 bed2 bath | Jan 13 2026 | $387,000 | 43 | 🎯100% | 2201 sq ft | $176 |
 SOLD 19650 Harbor Watch Court 3 bed3 bath | Jan 7 2026 | $740,000 | 279 | 98% | 2828 sq ft | $262 |
 SOLD 24558 Blue Heron Circle 402 4 bed4 bath | Dec 19 2025 | $421,340 | 248 | 🎯100% | 3022 sq ft | $139 |
 SOLD 50109 Robins Nest Lane 3 bed3 bath | Dec 19 2025 | $315,000 | 49 | 98% | 1642 sq ft | $192 |
 SOLD 10180 Lakeshore Drive 3 bed2 bath | Nov 26 2025 | $305,500 | 55 | 97% | 1890 sq ft | $162 |
 SOLD 9989 Jack Nicklaus Drive 921 5 bed4 bath | Nov 25 2025 | $430,000 | 75 | 98% | 3153 sq ft | $136 |
 SOLD 9971 Jack Nicklaus Drive 918 3 bed2 bath | Nov 21 2025 | $392,400 | 46 | 98% | 2296 sq ft | $171 |
12001 Sam Snead Court
$419,999
50139 Robins Nest Lane
$265,000
13125 Arnold Palmer Circle
$673,990
40117 Crooked Stick Drive
$292,000
9465 Tradewinds Court
$735,000
21260 Sanctuary Drive
$365,000
4642 Monterrico Drive
$443,151
4612 Monterrico Drive
$510,000
70147 Calcutta Lane
$282,895
4630 Monterrico Drive
$567,606
25968 Appleyard Court
$354,900
26043 Appleyard Court
$290,000
11058 Argosy Drive
$340,000
40199 Crooked Stick Drive
$359,000
5299 Admirals Landing
$475,000
24604 Blue Heron Circle
$265,000
10339 Lakeshore Drive 85
$350,000
13038 Arnold Palmer Circle 1053
$580,000
24613 Blue Heron Circle 432
$349,900
44010 Donald Ross Court 1028
$435,000
10315 Lakeshore Drive 89
$559,000
13032 Arnold Palmer Circle 1052
$519,400
5220 Admirals Landing
$337,000
10423 Lakeshore Drive 71
$387,000
19650 Harbor Watch Court
$740,000
24558 Blue Heron Circle 402
$421,340
50109 Robins Nest Lane
$315,000
10180 Lakeshore Drive
$305,500
9989 Jack Nicklaus Drive 921
$430,000
9971 Jack Nicklaus Drive 918
$392,400
Market Statistics
The Edgewater real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 115 days. With 49 active listings and 81 homes sold in the past year, Buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Pricing
Median Price:$387,000
Average Price:$395,430.6
Property Details
Avg Bedrooms:3.2
Avg Bathrooms:2.4
Avg Lot Size:0.34 acres
Market Activity
Active Listings:49
Sold Last Year:81
Median Days to Sell:115 days
Community Info
Median Year Built:2019
New Construction:12%
Recently Off Market Properties
20 propertiesLooking for similar properties?
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in Edgewater. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.