Buyers have more negotiating power. Properties may take longer to sell.
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 SOLD 407 Sugar Mill Road 5 bed3 bath | Jan 2 2026 | $765,000 | 76 | 🎯101% | 3782 sq ft | $202 |
 SOLD 111 Farm Valley Court 4 bed2 bath | Dec 1 2025 | $609,900 | 197 | 98% | 3126 sq ft | $195 |
 SOLD 211 S Ticonderoga Drive 4 bed2 bath | Oct 8 2025 | $675,000 | 104 | 98% | 3245 sq ft | $208 |
 SOLD 310 Water Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Sep 15 2025 | $669,000 | 67 | 97% | 3455 sq ft | $194 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 708 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Jul 11 2025 | $645,000 | 85 | 91% | 3281 sq ft | $197 |
 SOLD 505 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Jul 3 2025 | $699,000 | 70 | 🎯100% | 3311 sq ft | $211 |
 SOLD 108 Tarleton Way 4 bed2 bath | Jun 17 2025 | $650,000 | 87 | 99% | 3427 sq ft | $190 |
 SOLD 210 S Ticonderoga Drive 5 bed4 bath | May 13 2025 | $750,000 | 74 | 94% | 4337 sq ft | $173 |
10 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 408 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed3 bath | Jun 28 2024 | $785,000 | 27 | 🎯103% | — | — |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 207 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Apr 18 2024 | $659,900 | 32 | 🎯100% | — | — |
5 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 403 Sugar Mill Road 5 bed4 bath | Oct 31 2023 | $775,000 | 28 | 🎯101% | — | — |
7 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 203 S Ticonderoga Drive 4 bed2 bath | Mar 30 2023 | $740,000 | 47 | 🎯100% | — | — |
3 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 106 Plum Mill Lane 4 bed2 bath | Dec 16 2022 | $617,500 | 52 | 95% | — | — |
 SOLD 203 Water Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Oct 19 2022 | $629,500 | 61 | 97% | — | — |
 SOLD 307 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Sep 15 2022 | $715,000 | 26 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD 112 Water Mill Road 5 bed4 bath | Aug 16 2022 | $670,000 | 66 | 🎯103% | — | — |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 324 Water Mill Road 5 bed3 bath | Jun 2 2022 | $705,000 | 26 | 🎯108% | — | — |
3 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 701 Sugar Mill Rd 4 bed3 bath | Feb 10 2022 | $555,000 | 70 | 97% | 2813 sq ft | $197 |
 SOLD 212 S Ticonderoga Drive 5 bed3 bath | Jan 20 2022 | $625,000 | 68 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD 705 Sugar Mill Road 5 bed3 bath | Dec 15 2021 | $625,000 | 49 | 🎯104% | — | — |
5 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 406 Sugar Mill Road 5 bed3 bath | Jul 12 2021 | $510,000 | 36 | 🎯104% | — | — |
 SOLD 402 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Jun 10 2021 | $512,100 | 33 | 🎯103% | — | — |
 SOLD 109 Plum Mill Court 5 bed3 bath | Apr 15 2021 | $490,000 | 55 | 🎯102% | 3220 sq ft | $152 |
 SOLD 109 Plum Mill Court 5 bed3 bath | Apr 15 2021 | $490,000 | 54 | 🎯102% | — | — |
9 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 305 Sugar Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Jul 14 2020 | $415,000 | 90 | 97% | — | — |
 SOLD 316 Water Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | May 29 2020 | $399,400 | 97 | 97% | — | — |
 SOLD 314 Water Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Apr 30 2020 | $444,900 | 57 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD 112 Water Mill Road 5 bed3 bath | Mar 17 2020 | $479,000 | 143 | 96% | — | — |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 106 Plum Mill Court 4 bed2 bath | Oct 31 2019 | $468,500 | 68 | 🎯102% | — | — |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 308 Water Mill Road 4 bed2 bath | Jun 7 2019 | $400,000 | 34 | 95% | — | — |
407 Sugar Mill Road
$765,000
111 Farm Valley Court
$609,900
211 S Ticonderoga Drive
$675,000
310 Water Mill Road
$669,000
708 Sugar Mill Road
$645,000
505 Sugar Mill Road
$699,000
108 Tarleton Way
$650,000
210 S Ticonderoga Drive
$750,000
408 Sugar Mill Road
$785,000
207 Sugar Mill Road
$659,900
403 Sugar Mill Road
$775,000
203 S Ticonderoga Drive
$740,000
106 Plum Mill Lane
$617,500
203 Water Mill Road
$629,500
307 Sugar Mill Road
$715,000
112 Water Mill Road
$670,000
324 Water Mill Road
$705,000
701 Sugar Mill Rd
$555,000
212 S Ticonderoga Drive
$625,000
705 Sugar Mill Road
$625,000
406 Sugar Mill Road
$510,000
402 Sugar Mill Road
$512,100
109 Plum Mill Court
$490,000
109 Plum Mill Court
$490,000
305 Sugar Mill Road
$415,000
316 Water Mill Road
$399,400
314 Water Mill Road
$444,900
112 Water Mill Road
$479,000
106 Plum Mill Court
$468,500
308 Water Mill Road
$400,000
The Sugarmill real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 2846 days. With 2 active listings and 8 homes sold in the past year, Buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Median Price:$602,500
Average Price:$602,500
Avg Bedrooms:4.3
Avg Bathrooms:2.5
Avg Lot Size:0.34 acres
Active Listings:2
Sold Last Year:8
Median Days to Sell:2846 days
Has HOA:No
Median Year Built:1989
New Construction:0%
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in Sugarmill. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.
