Tahala Shores Homes for Sale in Cullowhee, SC

Browse 1 home for sale and recently sold properties in Tahala Shores, Cullowhee, SC.

Active: 1
Recently Sold: 6

Active

$557,000 $287/sqft

125 Tahala Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,944 sqft · 1 ac · 1999 · 27 d ago

Fireplace

Sold

$1,375,000 $463/sqft

1679 Woods Mountain Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

2 bd · 2 ba · 2,969 sqft · 1.2 ac · 1993 · DOM: 127 d

Fireplace Water Garage

Sold

Homesite

$39,500

14 Woods Mountain Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

DOM: 67 d

Water

Sold

$997,500 $350/sqft

278 Tahala Shores Trail 35

Cullowhee, NC 28723

4 bd · 3 ba · 2,848 sqft · 1 ac · 1984 · DOM: 830 d

Fireplace

Sold

$680,000 $392/sqft

256 S Woods Mountain Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,736 sqft · 1.1 ac · 1994 · DOM: 320 d

Fireplace Water

Sold

$599,900 $221/sqft

897 Woods Mountain Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

4 bd · 3 ba · 2,720 sqft · 1.6 ac · 2004 · DOM: 1519 d

Fireplace Water Garage

Sold

$524,900 $302/sqft

256 Woods Mountain Trail

Cullowhee, NC 28723

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,736 sqft · 1.1 ac · 1994 · DOM: 386 d

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Cullowhee

Ask about Tahala Shores — we answer fast

864-757-4000 Ask about Tahala Shores

Own a home in Tahala Shores?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Tahala Shores sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Tahala Shores

8.7 mi

Thorn Ridge, Sylva

2 active · $549,000

7.0 mi

Cedar Creek Farms, Tuckasegee

2 active · $157,500

8.0 mi

Cullasaja Club, Highlands

2 active · $3,447,500

9.9 mi

Holly Forest, Sapphire

6 active · $14,500

7.4 mi

Forest Hills, Cullowhee

4 active · $370,000

6.4 mi

Bear Lake Reserve, Tuckasegee

37 active · $499,000

Recently Sold in Tahala Shores 6 recently sold in Tahala Shores, Cullowhee with dates and property details ↓

Recently Sold

6 recently sold in Tahala Shores, Cullowhee

Property	Sold	Sold Price	Days on Market	Size	Sold to Ask	Sold $/SF
1679 Woods Mountain Trail 2 bd · 2 ba	Jun 3 2026	$1,200,000	127	2,969 sq ft	87.3%	$404
14 Woods Mountain Trail	Oct 30 2024	$32,500	67	—	82.3%	—
278 Tahala Shores Trail 35 4 bd · 3 ba	Dec 16 2019	$950,000	830	2,848 sq ft	95.2%	$334
256 S Woods Mountain Trail 3 bd · 3 ba	Oct 30 2019	$640,000	320	1,736 sq ft	94.1%	$369
897 Woods Mountain Trail 4 bd · 3 ba	Nov 8 2017	$560,000	1519	2,720 sq ft	93.3%	$206
256 Woods Mountain Trail 3 bd · 2 ba	Aug 5 2016	$455,000	386	1,736 sq ft	86.7%	$262

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Tahala Shores, Cullowhee

Not enough recent sales in Tahala Shores to chart a trend.

Last sale $1,200,000 Jun 3, 2026

See sold homes in Tahala Shores →

The Tahala Shores real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 353 days. With 1 active listing and 1 home sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.

Pricing

Median Price: $557,000
Average Price: $557,000
$/Sq.Ft (Q1): $262
1-Yr Price Trend: +3592.3%

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms: 3.0
Avg Bathrooms: 2.4
Avg Lot Size: 1.20 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings: 1
Sold Last Year: 1
Median Days to Sell: 353 days

Community Info

Median Year Built: 1994
New Construction: 0%

Call Map