St Johns Forest Homes for Sale
3 homes
Market Trends
Buyers have more negotiating power. Properties may take longer to sell. Prices have declined 9%.
Year-over-Year Comparison
Last 12 months
Recently Sold Properties
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 SOLD 4418 Kiddle Lane 4 bed2 bath | Feb 27 2026 | $360,000 | 98 | 97% | 2682 sq ft | $134 |
 SOLD 4419 Red Hook Road 3 bed2 bath | Feb 26 2026 | $330,000 | 183 | 🎯100% | 1815 sq ft | $182 |
 SOLD 215 Lind Point Lane 4 bed2 bath | Jan 27 2026 | $415,000 | 60 | 🎯104% | 2917 sq ft | $142 |
 SOLD 4604 Manchineel Lane 4 bed2 bath | Jan 20 2026 | $373,500 | 47 | 94% | 2726 sq ft | $137 |
 SOLD 4616 Maho Lane 3 bed2 bath | Dec 29 2025 | $350,000 | 40 | 99% | 1982 sq ft | $177 |
 SOLD 4619 Maho Lane 4 bed2 bath | Oct 30 2025 | $410,000 | 48 | 98% | 2945 sq ft | $139 |
 SOLD 4724 Kiddle Lane 4 bed2 bath | Oct 9 2025 | $395,000 | 70 | 96% | 2914 sq ft | $136 |
 SOLD 5009 Manchineel Lane 3 bed2 bath | Sep 26 2025 | $320,000 | 39 | 97% | 1636 sq ft | $196 |
 SOLD 4513 Red Hook Road 4 bed2 bath | Sep 11 2025 | $368,000 | 50 | 98% | 2087 sq ft | $176 |
 SOLD 305 Lameshur Lane 3 bed2 bath | Sep 3 2025 | $330,000 | 39 | 92% | 2274 sq ft | $145 |
 SOLD 409 Bougainvillea Court 5 bed2 bath | Aug 29 2025 | $384,000 | 58 | 92% | 3048 sq ft | $126 |
 SOLD 512 Nanny Point Drive 4 bed3 bath | Jul 14 2025 | $410,000 | 52 | 98% | 3107 sq ft | $132 |
 SOLD 422 Bougainvillea Court 4 bed3 bath | Jun 23 2025 | $395,000 | 375 | 🎯100% | 2919 sq ft | $135 |
 SOLD 4424 Red Hook Road 4 bed2 bath | Jun 20 2025 | $390,000 | 246 | 95% | 2196 sq ft | $178 |
 SOLD 4919 Manchineel Lane 4 bed2 bath | May 22 2025 | $390,000 | 49 | 98% | 2750 sq ft | $142 |
 SOLD 203 Waterlemon Way 4 bed2 bath | May 13 2025 | $372,000 | 57 | 97% | 2251 sq ft | $165 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 207 Lameshur Lane 3 bed2 bath | Feb 21 2025 | $365,000 | 36 | 🎯100% | 2148 sq ft | $170 |
 SOLD 4430 Red Hook Road 4 bed2 bath | Feb 18 2025 | $360,000 | 162 | 95% | 2245 sq ft | $160 |
 SOLD 514 Nanny Point Drive 5 bed3 bath | Feb 7 2025 | $417,000 | 137 | 98% | 3500 sq ft | $119 |
 SOLD 5115 Cruz Bay Drive 3 bed2 bath | Jan 13 2025 | $354,000 | 58 | 99% | 1958 sq ft | $181 |
 SOLD 209 Annaberg Lane 3 bed2 bath | Dec 10 2024 | $380,000 | 53 | 99% | 2041 sq ft | $186 |
 SOLD 714 Waterlemon Way 4 bed2 bath | Nov 12 2024 | $370,000 | 46 | 99% | 2252 sq ft | $164 |
 SOLD 221 Lind Point Lane 4 bed2 bath | Oct 3 2024 | $386,500 | 50 | 98% | 2261 sq ft | $171 |
 SOLD 4424 Red Hook Road 4 bed2 bath | Sep 18 2024 | $342,500 | 86 | 95% | 2095 sq ft | $163 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 405 Waterlemon Way 3 bed2 bath | Jun 28 2024 | $366,000 | 76 | 🎯103% | 2242 sq ft | $163 |
 SOLD 5011 Manchineel Lane 3 bed2 bath | Jun 25 2024 | $350,000 | 46 | 🎯100% | 1820 sq ft | $192 |
 SOLD 503 Waterlemon Way 3 bed2 bath | Jun 14 2024 | $340,000 | 43 | 97% | 1858 sq ft | $183 |
 SOLD 4420 Red Hook Road 4 bed2 bath | Jun 13 2024 | $400,000 | 34 | 🎯100% | 2207 sq ft | $181 |
 SOLD 407 Lind Point Lane 4 bed2 bath | Jun 12 2024 | $400,000 | 40 | 🎯100% | 2284 sq ft | $175 |
 SOLD 4822 Manchineel Lane 3 bed2 bath | May 31 2024 | $291,100 | 45 | 87% | 1750 sq ft | $166 |
4418 Kiddle Lane
$360,000
4419 Red Hook Road
$330,000
215 Lind Point Lane
$415,000
4604 Manchineel Lane
$373,500
4616 Maho Lane
$350,000
4619 Maho Lane
$410,000
4724 Kiddle Lane
$395,000
5009 Manchineel Lane
$320,000
4513 Red Hook Road
$368,000
305 Lameshur Lane
$330,000
409 Bougainvillea Court
$384,000
512 Nanny Point Drive
$410,000
422 Bougainvillea Court
$395,000
4424 Red Hook Road
$390,000
4919 Manchineel Lane
$390,000
203 Waterlemon Way
$372,000
207 Lameshur Lane
$365,000
4430 Red Hook Road
$360,000
514 Nanny Point Drive
$417,000
5115 Cruz Bay Drive
$354,000
209 Annaberg Lane
$380,000
714 Waterlemon Way
$370,000
221 Lind Point Lane
$386,500
4424 Red Hook Road
$342,500
405 Waterlemon Way
$366,000
5011 Manchineel Lane
$350,000
503 Waterlemon Way
$340,000
4420 Red Hook Road
$400,000
407 Lind Point Lane
$400,000
4822 Manchineel Lane
$291,100
Market Statistics
The St Johns Forest real estate market shows balanced market conditions. Homes typically sell within 59 days. With 3 active listings and 16 homes sold in the past year, A healthy balance between buyers and sellers.
Pricing
Median Price:$339,000
Average Price:$357,966.66
Property Details
Avg Bedrooms:3.5
Avg Bathrooms:2.1
Avg Lot Size:0.15 acres
Market Activity
Active Listings:3
Sold Last Year:16
Median Days to Sell:59 days
Community Info
Has HOA:No
Median Year Built:2008
New Construction:0%
Recently Off Market Properties
2 propertiesLooking for similar properties?
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in St Johns Forest. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.