Skip to main content

Pilgrim Forest Homes for Sale in Monroe, SC

Pilgrim Forest feels like one of Monroe’s classic acreage neighborhoods, where wooded settings, long driveways, and generous setbacks shape the first impression.

Active
1
Recently Sold
19

Active & Pending Listings

About Pilgrim Forest

Community overview based on MLS listing data for Pilgrim Forest, Monroe

First Impressions

Pilgrim Forest feels like one of Monroe’s classic acreage neighborhoods, where wooded settings, long driveways, and generous setbacks shape the first impression. The streetscape is defined by larger homesites and a relaxed, established look rather than close-together subdivision construction. Recent listings point to a community that can range from modest ranch homes to more customized residences with wraparound porches, semi-circular drives, and expansive outdoor space.

"Wooded lots and room to spread out give Pilgrim Forest its unmistakable character."

Home Styles & Community Feel

Single-family homes are the clear norm here, and the architecture leans toward ranch and transitional designs with practical layouts. Many homes feature updated kitchens, hardwood or bamboo flooring, granite counters, bonus rooms, screened or covered porches, and detached storage or workshop space. Several properties also highlight large decks and flexible outbuildings, which suits the neighborhood’s spacious lot pattern well. The setting is especially appealing if you value privacy, mature trees, and the ability to customize a property over time. Lot sizes are notably generous, with plenty of acreage-style parcels mixed into the community’s housing fabric.

Amenities & Daily Rhythm

Pilgrim Forest does not revolve around a clubhouse or amenity package; instead, its appeal comes from land, elbow room, and the everyday usefulness of having space outdoors. Some homes include garages, carports, sheds, and even barn-style outbuildings, while others lean into open yards, gardens, patios, and screened porches. The rhythm here is slower and more residential, with homes set back from the road and outdoor living taking center stage. One recent listing also noted county water availability and a completed perk test, reinforcing the practical side of building and improvement opportunities in the neighborhood.

"This is a place where the lot matters as much as the house."

Location & Schools

Pilgrim Forest sits off Pilgrim Forest Drive in Monroe, with remarks pointing to easy access toward Wesley Chapel, Goldmine Road, and the Sun Valley area. That puts shopping and dining within a short drive, including Wesley Commons Shopping, the new Publix, and restaurants and retail in Wesley Chapel or Sun Valley. Public remarks also describe the community as close to shopping, movies, and restaurants, while still keeping its wooded, country-leaning feel. School references consistently point to Sun Valley Middle and Sun Valley High, with one older listing also noting the Weddington High School area and Union County schools. For buyers who want space without giving up access to daily conveniences, Pilgrim Forest lands in a practical spot with a distinctly rural edge.

Questions about Pilgrim Forest?

Palmetto Park Realty Team · Monroe

Ask about Pilgrim Forest — we answer fast

Own a home in Pilgrim Forest?

See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Pilgrim Forest sales, free.

What's my home worth?

Nearby Communities

Communities similar to Pilgrim Forest

Recently Sold in Pilgrim Forest 19 recently sold in Pilgrim Forest, Monroe with dates and property details

Recently Sold

19 recently sold in Pilgrim Forest, Monroe

Property Sold Sold Price Days on Market Size Sold to Ask Sold $/SF
800 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 800 Pilgrim Forest Drive Jun 18 2026 $181,000 21 91.0%
905 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 905 Pilgrim Forest Drive 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 10 2024 $450,000 47 1,810 sq ft 103.4% $249
1001 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1001 Mayflower Trail 5 bd · 3 ba Jun 21 2024 $539,000 94 2,717 sq ft 101.9% $198
916 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 916 Pilgrim Forest Drive 4 bd · 2 ba May 12 2023 $448,500 36 2,128 sq ft 104.3% $211
901 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 901 Pilgrim Forest Drive 3 bd · 2 ba Apr 27 2023 $434,900 96 1,988 sq ft 100.0% $219
1001 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1001 Mayflower Trail 5 bd · 3 ba Dec 8 2022 $515,000 99 2,819 sq ft 96.3% $183
0 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 0 Mayflower Trail Sep 16 2022 $75,000 16 75.0%
903 Bradford Place sold home in Monroe, SC 903 Bradford Place 4 bd · 3 ba Apr 14 2022 $480,000 42 3,570 sq ft 96.6% $134
811 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 811 Pilgrim Forest Drive 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 8 2021 $375,000 35 1,767 sq ft 100.0% $212
1011 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1011 Mayflower Trail 5 bd · 3 ba Jul 23 2021 $525,000 58 3,024 sq ft 61.8% $174
1002 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1002 Mayflower Trail 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 12 2019 $270,000 67 2,160 sq ft 96.8% $125
717 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 717 Pilgrim Forest Drive 4 bd · 2 ba Mar 14 2019 $357,000 175 2,890 sq ft 95.2% $124
901 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 901 Pilgrim Forest Drive 3 bd · 2 ba May 29 2018 $248,000 46 1,979 sq ft 94.7% $125
1001 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1001 Mayflower Trail 3 bd · 2 ba Oct 16 2017 $110,000 149 2,703 sq ft 91.7% $41
920 Pilgrim Forest Drive 14 sold home in Monroe, SC 920 Pilgrim Forest Drive 14 4 bd · 2 ba Dec 14 2016 $155,000 57 3,200 sq ft 96.9% $48
1002 Mayflower Trail sold home in Monroe, SC 1002 Mayflower Trail 3 bd · 2 ba Aug 22 2016 $215,000 59 2,160 sq ft 95.6% $100
1002 Mayflower Trail 42 & 43 sold home in Monroe, SC 1002 Mayflower Trail 42 & 43 3 bd · 2 ba Nov 20 2015 $100,000 53 2,268 sq ft 55.6% $44
801 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 801 Pilgrim Forest Drive 4 bd · 4 ba Aug 10 2015 $279,000 67 2,182 sq ft 93.3% $128
708 Pilgrim Forest Drive sold home in Monroe, SC 708 Pilgrim Forest Drive 3 bd · 2 ba Jul 9 2013 $105,097 57 1,758 sq ft 116.9% $60

Market Trends

Closed sales from MLS history for Pilgrim Forest, Monroe

Monroe 1 yr ▾ 0.9%

Below trend-line threshold — city median shown for context

+1 outside price range.

$200k $300k $400k $500k 20222023202420252026 $392k Monroe Sales closed per quarter peak 2

The Pilgrim Forest real estate market shows balanced market conditions. Homes typically sell within 57 days. With 1 active listing and 1 home sold in the past year, a healthy balance exists between buyers and sellers.

Pricing

Median Price
$690,000
Average Price
$690,000
$/Sq.Ft (Q1)
$100

Property Details

Avg Bedrooms
3.7
Avg Bathrooms
2.3
Avg Lot Size
2.89 acres

Market Activity

Active Listings
1
Sold Last Year
1
Median Days to Sell
57 days

Community Info

Median Year Built
1979
New Construction
0%
Call Map

Add a place

Listing alerts

Save this search

Choose a name and how often you want new-match alerts.

You can remove alerts any time from Saved searches.