
$740,000 $217/sqft
5409 Poplar Knoll Drive
Matthews, NC 28105
5 bd · 3 ba · 3,403 sqft · 2013 · 1 mo ago
Poplar Forest has the polished, established feel of a Matthews neighborhood that knows exactly what it is: a collection of brick homes, well-kept streets, and outdoor spaces that make daily life feel orderly and composed.
Community overview based on MLS listing data for Poplar Forest, Matthews
Poplar Forest has the polished, established feel of a Matthews neighborhood that knows exactly what it is: a collection of brick homes, well-kept streets, and outdoor spaces that make daily life feel orderly and composed. The setting leans residential and refined, with many homes offering front porches, mature landscaping, and a strong sense of curb appeal. Brick is a defining visual theme here, often paired with stone accents, gabled roofs, and generous driveways.
"Brick exteriors, manicured yards, and easy access to Matthews staples give Poplar Forest its signature charm."
Most homes here are single-family residences built in the 2000s and early 2010s, with a few older examples stretching back to the 1970s. The architecture favors open layouts, hardwood floors, tray ceilings, formal dining rooms, and spacious kitchens with granite, stainless appliances, and islands. Many properties also include screened porches, paver patios, and private backyards framed by mature trees or wooded edges.
Garage space is a standout feature, and several homes offer oversized or three-car garages, adding real everyday convenience. The community’s lot sizes are comfortable rather than sprawling, which helps create a cohesive streetscape without sacrificing usable outdoor space. Overall, Poplar Forest feels thoughtfully maintained and visibly upgraded, with a strong preference for timeless finishes over trendy design.
The rhythm of Poplar Forest is shaped by low-maintenance living and outdoor enjoyment. HOA-covered lawn care appears to be a consistent part of the neighborhood experience, and irrigation systems are commonly included as well. That means more time spent on the screened porch, the patio, or the front rocking chair porch, and less time spent on yard work. Mature landscaping, wooded backdrops, and landscaped common edges give the neighborhood a settled, cared-for look.
"This is a neighborhood where the outdoor spaces are as polished as the interiors."
Nearby recreation and errands are a major part of the appeal. Squirrel Lake Park, Colonel Francis Beatty Park, the Brace Y, Publix, Waverly, and the Fincher Farms area all come up as part of the day-to-day landscape, along with Downtown Matthews for dining and local events. Residents also mention easy access to I-485 and quick trips to shopping centers and fitness options.
Poplar Forest sits in Matthews near Savannah Hills Drive and the Poplar Knoll area, with a convenient position for reaching both local and regional destinations. Public remarks point to about 5 minutes to Fincher Farms, less than 5 minutes to McKee Farms shopping center, 1.6 miles to Publix and dining, and quick access to I-485. Downtown Matthews, Squirrel Lake Park, Colonel Francis Beatty Park, Ballantyne, and uptown Charlotte are all referenced as nearby destinations, giving the neighborhood a practical location without feeling commercial.
School assignments are Matthews Elementary, Crestdale Middle, and Butler High. That school pairing, along with the neighborhood’s Matthews setting and strong access to parks, shopping, and commuter routes, helps define Poplar Forest as a well-situated residential pocket with a distinctly finished look.
Palmetto Park Realty Team · Matthews
Ask about Poplar Forest — we answer fast
See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Poplar Forest sales, free.
What's my home worth?Communities similar to Poplar Forest
1.4 mi Greylock, Matthews
2 active · $722,000
1.2 mi Weddington Ridge, Matthews
3 active · $595,000
1.4 mi Thornblade, Matthews
2 active · $657,250
0.6 mi Providence Hills, Matthews
2 active · $846,950
0.8 mi Brightmoor, Matthews
3 active · $529,000
2.2 mi Hampton Green, Matthews
2 active · $625,000
Showing 1-48+ recently sold in Poplar Forest, Matthews
| Property | Sold | Sold Price | Days on Market | Size | Sold to Ask | Sold $/SF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| | Jun 12 2026 | $530,000 | 42 | 2,150 sq ft | 96.4% | $247 |
| | Apr 2 2026 | $659,000 | 55 | 3,395 sq ft | 100.0% | $194 |
| | Mar 26 2026 | $525,000 | 115 | 2,062 sq ft | 99.1% | $255 |
| | Apr 25 2025 | $590,000 | 126 | 2,566 sq ft | 100.5% | $230 |
| | Feb 18 2025 | $650,000 | 54 | 3,145 sq ft | 100.0% | $207 |
| | Aug 5 2024 | $606,000 | 40 | 2,919 sq ft | 101.0% | $208 |
| | May 2 2024 | $585,000 | 28 | 2,267 sq ft | 106.4% | $258 |
| | Feb 27 2024 | $575,000 | 33 | 2,764 sq ft | 101.8% | $208 |
| | Oct 26 2023 | $575,000 | 62 | 2,655 sq ft | 98.6% | $217 |
| | May 9 2023 | $520,000 | 32 | 2,149 sq ft | 100.0% | $242 |
| | Dec 17 2021 | $510,000 | 25 | 2,609 sq ft | 105.2% | $195 |
| | Nov 30 2021 | $500,000 | 38 | 2,622 sq ft | 103.1% | $191 |
| | Oct 28 2021 | $410,000 | 41 | 2,121 sq ft | 107.9% | $193 |
| | Aug 27 2021 | $470,000 | 46 | 2,762 sq ft | 97.3% | $170 |
| | Apr 7 2021 | $435,000 | 40 | 2,542 sq ft | 103.6% | $171 |
| | Feb 5 2021 | $362,000 | 105 | 2,716 sq ft | 97.8% | $133 |
| | Nov 18 2020 | $410,000 | 34 | 2,562 sq ft | 102.5% | $160 |
| | Mar 13 2020 | $360,000 | 69 | 2,528 sq ft | 96.0% | $142 |
| | Mar 12 2020 | $342,500 | 42 | 2,806 sq ft | 97.9% | $122 |
| | Jan 7 2020 | $365,000 | 166 | 2,978 sq ft | 98.7% | $123 |
| | Oct 25 2019 | $338,000 | 58 | 2,748 sq ft | 99.4% | $123 |
| | Jul 19 2019 | $343,000 | 63 | 2,715 sq ft | 95.3% | $126 |
| | Dec 20 2018 | $412,500 | 145 | 3,473 sq ft | 97.3% | $119 |
| | Oct 19 2018 | $365,000 | 180 | 2,998 sq ft | 96.6% | $122 |
| | Oct 19 2018 | $396,500 | 64 | 2,994 sq ft | 100.4% | $132 |
| | Sep 12 2018 | $362,000 | 131 | 2,799 sq ft | 99.0% | $129 |
| | Jul 31 2018 | $357,000 | 81 | 2,566 sq ft | 95.2% | $139 |
| | Jul 27 2018 | $350,000 | 78 | 2,170 sq ft | 100.0% | $161 |
| | Mar 14 2018 | $330,000 | 102 | 3,015 sq ft | 95.7% | $109 |
| | Feb 27 2018 | $359,000 | 43 | 2,540 sq ft | 99.7% | $141 |
| | Oct 2 2017 | $340,000 | 84 | 2,128 sq ft | 98.6% | $160 |
| | Jul 10 2017 | $358,000 | 63 | 2,539 sq ft | 100.0% | $141 |
| | Mar 30 2017 | $302,900 | 247 | 2,660 sq ft | 101.3% | $114 |
| | Mar 30 2017 | $318,000 | 196 | 2,267 sq ft | 96.5% | $140 |
| | Mar 2 2017 | $300,000 | 163 | 2,510 sq ft | 96.8% | $120 |
| | Jan 30 2017 | $345,000 | 87 | 2,812 sq ft | 98.6% | $123 |
| | Nov 22 2016 | $325,000 | 174 | 2,899 sq ft | 95.9% | $112 |
| | Oct 27 2016 | $345,000 | 30 | 2,535 sq ft | 98.6% | $136 |
| | Aug 24 2016 | $312,000 | 286 | 2,660 sq ft | 91.9% | $117 |
| | Mar 9 2016 | $301,000 | 128 | 2,646 sq ft | 97.9% | $114 |
| | Feb 29 2016 | $289,900 | 82 | 2,096 sq ft | 100.0% | $138 |
| | Sep 30 2015 | $340,000 | 83 | 3,791 sq ft | 98.1% | $90 |
| | Jul 31 2015 | $332,220 | 190 | 2,429 sq ft | 93.8% | $137 |
| | Jul 10 2015 | $314,900 | 169 | 2,627 sq ft | 98.5% | $120 |
| | May 28 2015 | $320,000 | 419 | 2,623 sq ft | 94.8% | $122 |
| | Feb 18 2015 | $294,000 | 69 | 2,827 sq ft | 96.5% | $104 |
| | Oct 16 2014 | $300,190 | 108 | 2,627 sq ft | 92.4% | $114 |
| | Oct 7 2014 | $265,000 | 158 | 2,956 sq ft | 94.6% | $90 |
Closed sales from MLS history for Poplar Forest, Matthews
Poplar Forest median sale price is $470,000; Matthews is down 1.0%.
The Poplar Forest real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 87 days. With 1 active listing and 3 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.