Nightingale Hill Homes for Sale

First Impressions

Nightingale Hill has the feel of a brand-new pocket neighborhood: compact in scale, cohesive in appearance, and clearly shaped around fresh construction rather than resale turnover. The homes recorded here were built in 2024 and 2025, and recent asking prices have generally landed from the upper $200s into the mid $300s, which gives the community a polished, move-in-ready profile within Lexington. It is a small section, and that comes through in the experience of it. Instead of a sprawling subdivision with dozens of phases, Nightingale Hill reads as a tighter collection of newer homes that already feels defined.

Home Styles & Community Feel

Single-family homes set the tone throughout the neighborhood, with most properties offering four bedrooms and three baths. Floor plans commonly fall around 2,075 to 2,411 square feet, while one smaller three-bedroom design around 1,400 square feet broadens the mix. McGuinn Homes appears repeatedly in the listing history, especially through the Cypress and Hawthorne plans, so there is a strong sense of continuity from one address to the next. Interiors lean toward the finishes buyers expect from current construction: open living areas, nine-foot ceilings, quartz countertops, luxury vinyl plank flooring, tile backsplashes, walk-in pantries, and stainless appliances. Several homes also highlight fenced backyards, corner lots, covered porches, or decks looking toward wooded common space, giving the neighborhood a little more texture than a simple row of new houses.