Hickory Hill Homes for Sale
2 homes
Community Highlights
- Access to Lake Junaluska amenities including golf, pool, tennis, and the lakeside walking trail
- Wooded homesites that commonly range from about one-half acre to more than one acre
- A mix of established custom homes and remaining buildable lots within the same neighborhood
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
lakeside route
Fishing · Kayaking · Paddle Boarding
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Architecture & Style
- Open Floor Plans
- Covered Porches And Decks
- Main Level Primary Suites
- Finished Basements
- Hardwood Floors
- Bonus Or Flex Space
- Mountain Views
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Location & Proximity
Haywood County mountain lake setting
- Lake Junaluska lakeside trail
- Downtown Waynesville
- Haywood Regional Medical Center
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Lots and Land in Hickory Hill
Hickory Hill is one of Lake Junaluska's more spacious residential pockets, mixing established custom homes with a final wave of wooded homesites on the hillside above the lake. The setting leans distinctly mountain-residential: cul-de-sac streets, frequent mountain and lake outlooks, and lot sizes that often stretch from roughly half an acre to more than an acre.
Community Highlights
Most improved properties in Hickory Hill were built between 1999 and 2021, with the heaviest concentration from the late 1990s through 2010. The homes that surface here tend to be detached three- to six-bedroom layouts with open living areas, generous decks or covered porches, and a recurring preference for main-level primary suites and finished lower levels. Custom detailing shows up often, from tongue-and-groove ceilings and built-ins to walk-in pantries, hardwood floors, and flexible bonus space. Methodist Drive and the cul-de-sacs off Hoosier, Susannah, Sarah, and Samuel courts give the neighborhood a tucked-away feel while still keeping the broader Lake Junaluska campus close at hand.
These insights are based on listing details and are informational only; verify details for any specific property.
Market Trends
Buyers have more negotiating power. Properties may take longer to sell. Prices have increased 1030%. There's typically room for negotiation on price.
Year-over-Year Comparison
Last 12 months
Recently Sold Properties
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 SOLD 39 Susannah Court 6 bed4 bath | Nov 4 2025 | $565,000 | 239 | 94% | 2715 sq ft | $208 |
5 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 12 Hoosier Court 3 bed2 bath | Jun 3 2025 | $431,000 | 22 | 🎯101% | 1246 sq ft | $346 |
 SOLD 0000 Hoosier Court 103 | May 19 2025 | $50,000 | 532 | 77% | — | — |
10 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD L 106 Hoosier Court | Jun 24 2024 | $90,000 | 6568 | 89% | — | — |
 SOLD 415 Methodist Drive 4 bed4 bath | May 30 2024 | $825,000 | 26 | 🎯111% | 3256 sq ft | $253 |
 SOLD 55 Sarah Court 4 bed3 bath | May 1 2024 | $585,900 | 172 | 🎯100% | 3868 sq ft | $151 |
10 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 37 Samuel Court 4 bed2 bath | Jun 15 2023 | $499,000 | 48 | 🎯100% | 2408 sq ft | $207 |
8 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 39 Susannah Court 6 bed4 bath | Oct 17 2022 | $586,813 | 81 | 🎯100% | 2715 sq ft | $216 |
3 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD L 99 Hoosier Court | Jun 21 2022 | $52,500 | 5834 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 100 Hoosier Court | May 19 2022 | $52,500 | 5801 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 102 Hoosier Court | May 19 2022 | $56,500 | 5801 | 🎯100% | — | — |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD 415 Methodist Drive 4 bed4 bath | Mar 16 2022 | $672,000 | 226 | 98% | 3359 sq ft | $200 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD L 107 Hoosier Court | Jan 5 2022 | $73,000 | 5667 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD 35 Susannah Court 3 bed2 bath | Dec 1 2021 | $600,000 | 45 | 🎯100% | 2622 sq ft | $229 |
 SOLD 85 Denman Drive | Nov 22 2021 | $100,000 | 30 | 95% | — | — |
3 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD L 98 Hoosier Court | Aug 20 2021 | $60,500 | 5529 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 101 Hoosier Court | Aug 20 2021 | $85,000 | 5529 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 95 Methodist Drive | Aug 2 2021 | $52,500 | 5511 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 84 Denman Drive | Jul 8 2021 | $68,750 | 5486 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD 00 Susannah Court | Jun 18 2021 | $42,500 | 63 | 87% | — | — |
 SOLD L 103 Hoosier Court | Jun 9 2021 | $31,250 | 5457 | 🎯100% | — | — |
 SOLD L 87 Denman Drive | May 4 2021 | $72,500 | 316 | 85% | — | — |
4 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD L 105 Hoosier Court | Dec 29 2020 | $75,000 | 5295 | 90% | — | — |
 SOLD Lot 91 Denman Drive | Dec 7 2020 | $97,500 | 59 | 98% | — | — |
 SOLD 66 Hoosier Court 4 bed3 bath | Nov 12 2020 | $419,000 | 71 | 🎯100% | 2828 sq ft | $148 |
2 month gap in market activity | ||||||
 SOLD Lot 39 Sarah Court | Sep 1 2020 | $48,000 | 77 | 96% | — | — |
 SOLD L 104 Hoosier Court | Jul 6 2020 | $65,000 | 5119 | 89% | — | — |
 SOLD 85 Denman Drive | May 22 2020 | $60,000 | 229 | 86% | — | — |
 SOLD Lot 1 Methodist Drive | May 8 2020 | $32,500 | 53 | 82% | — | — |
 SOLD 37 Samuel Court 4 bed2 bath | Apr 17 2020 | $332,900 | 45 | 🎯101% | 2464 sq ft | $135 |
39 Susannah Court
$565,000
12 Hoosier Court
$431,000
0000 Hoosier Court 103
$50,000
L 106 Hoosier Court
$90,000
415 Methodist Drive
$825,000
55 Sarah Court
$585,900
37 Samuel Court
$499,000
39 Susannah Court
$586,813
L 99 Hoosier Court
$52,500
L 100 Hoosier Court
$52,500
L 102 Hoosier Court
$56,500
415 Methodist Drive
$672,000
L 107 Hoosier Court
$73,000
35 Susannah Court
$600,000
85 Denman Drive
$100,000
L 98 Hoosier Court
$60,500
L 101 Hoosier Court
$85,000
L 95 Methodist Drive
$52,500
L 84 Denman Drive
$68,750
00 Susannah Court
$42,500
L 103 Hoosier Court
$31,250
L 87 Denman Drive
$72,500
L 105 Hoosier Court
$75,000
Lot 91 Denman Drive
$97,500
66 Hoosier Court
$419,000
Lot 39 Sarah Court
$48,000
L 104 Hoosier Court
$65,000
85 Denman Drive
$60,000
Lot 1 Methodist Drive
$32,500
37 Samuel Court
$332,900
Market Statistics
The Hickory Hill real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 236 days. With 2 active listings and 3 homes sold in the past year, Buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Pricing
Median Price:$748,500
Average Price:$748,500
Property Details
Avg Bedrooms:4.0
Avg Bathrooms:3.0
Avg Lot Size:0.66 acres
Market Activity
Active Listings:2
Sold Last Year:3
Median Days to Sell:236 days
Community Info
Has HOA:No
Median Year Built:2004
New Construction:0%
Recently Off Market Properties
1 propertyLooking for similar properties?
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in Hickory Hill. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.