
$379,000 $224/sqft
926 Toxaway Court
Hendersonville, NC 28791
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,693 sqft · 1966 · 12 d ago
Indian Hill is an established North Hendersonville neighborhood where mature trees, rolling terrain, and larger homesites shape the streetscape more than density does.
Community overview based on MLS listing data for Indian Hill, Hendersonville
Indian Hill is an established North Hendersonville neighborhood where mature trees, rolling terrain, and larger homesites shape the streetscape more than density does. The community’s strongest draw is the combination of close-in convenience and a noticeably more private setting: homes are routinely marketed as being just 5 to 10 minutes from downtown Hendersonville, yet many sit on wooded lots, double lots, or parcels that push past a half acre.
The housing stock is primarily single-family and largely dates from the 1960s through early 1980s, with most resale activity centered on homes built between 1966 and 1976. Brick is a recurring exterior material, especially among the ranch-style homes that anchor the neighborhood, but the overall character is mixed rather than uniform. Garages are the norm, basements are common, and many homes add flexible square footage through lower-level bonus rooms, workshops, recreation rooms, or media space. Fireplaces appear in most listings, and outdoor living shows up just as often through decks, patios, sunrooms, and screened porches.
Indian Hill does not read like a subdivision built around a clubhouse or pool package. Instead, its appeal comes from private-property features and the natural setting around the neighborhood. Mature landscaping, garden spaces, stone walls, wooded backdrops, and established planting beds appear again and again, giving many addresses a settled, park-like feel. Several homes highlight winter mountain views, while others look toward ponds, creeks, or Indian Hill Lake.
That water element is one of the neighborhood’s more distinctive touches. A small group of homes backs directly to the lake, and other listings mention pond views, creek frontage, or paths leading to the water. Those sites tend to carry more of the premium positioning within the neighborhood. The broadest price strength appears along Indian Hill Road, where closed-sale averages run above the community’s overall resale average and homesites are often larger.
Indian Hill sits on the north side of Hendersonville in the Blue Ridge foothills, with straightforward access to downtown, the US-25 corridor, and Asheville-area destinations. Listing remarks repeatedly frame downtown Hendersonville as a short drive, and Asheville plus the regional airport are commonly described as easy trips from the neighborhood. The most common school pattern in community records is Bruce Drysdale Elementary, Hendersonville Middle, and Hendersonville High.
Indian Hill’s identity is rooted in established construction, generous lot sizes, and flexible homes with room to spread out. For buyers comparing close-in Hendersonville neighborhoods, it stands out for privacy, mature landscaping, and the unusual presence of lake- and pond-oriented homesites within a mostly traditional single-family setting.
Palmetto Park Realty Team · Hendersonville
Ask about Indian Hill — we answer fast
See what it's worth — your home's own sale history plus recent Indian Hill sales, free.
What's my home worth?Communities similar to Indian Hill
1.7 mi Laurel Park, Hendersonville
3 active · $1,400,000
1.3 mi Druid Hills, Hendersonville
6 active · $445,998
1.0 mi Carriage Park, Hendersonville
36 active · $647,199
0.5 mi Creekside, Hendersonville
3 active · $699,000
2.3 mi Country Club Estates, Hendersonville
2 active · $301,000
2.1 mi Davis Mountain Views, Hendersonville
2 active · $598,500
40 recently sold in Indian Hill, Hendersonville
| Property | Sold | Sold Price | Days on Market | Size | Sold to Ask | Sold $/SF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| | Jan 20 2026 | $360,000 | 56 | — | 102.9% | — |
| | Dec 10 2025 | $463,000 | 167 | 2,790 sq ft | 97.5% | $166 |
| | Dec 8 2025 | $415,000 | 438 | 3,086 sq ft | 90.2% | $134 |
| | Aug 15 2025 | $455,000 | 87 | 2,130 sq ft | 98.2% | $214 |
| | Jun 18 2025 | $775,000 | 107 | 2,775 sq ft | 93.9% | $279 |
| | Jun 6 2025 | $669,000 | 53 | 2,505 sq ft | 100.0% | $267 |
| | Jan 22 2025 | $442,000 | 51 | 1,822 sq ft | 96.1% | $243 |
| | Nov 15 2022 | $490,000 | 47 | 2,754 sq ft | 97.0% | $178 |
| | Nov 7 2022 | $1,200,000 | 171 | 5,610 sq ft | 83.9% | $214 |
| | Sep 2 2022 | $585,000 | 39 | 2,492 sq ft | 97.7% | $235 |
| | Jun 17 2022 | $657,000 | 36 | 2,514 sq ft | 115.3% | $261 |
| | May 24 2022 | $470,000 | 54 | 1,944 sq ft | 115.9% | $242 |
| | May 10 2022 | $534,290 | 36 | 2,628 sq ft | 109.1% | $203 |
| | Jun 23 2021 | $355,000 | 48 | 1,594 sq ft | 101.4% | $223 |
| | Jun 21 2021 | $335,000 | 52 | 2,028 sq ft | 104.7% | $165 |
| | Sep 23 2020 | $813,000 | 416 | 5,268 sq ft | 95.6% | $154 |
| | Sep 27 2019 | $259,999 | 46 | 1,770 sq ft | 100.0% | $147 |
| | Mar 12 2019 | $295,000 | 169 | 2,257 sq ft | 98.3% | $131 |
| | May 30 2018 | $230,000 | 55 | 2,600 sq ft | 102.2% | $88 |
| | May 24 2018 | $278,000 | 48 | 2,430 sq ft | 95.9% | $114 |
| | Mar 12 2018 | $323,000 | 171 | 2,418 sq ft | 95.4% | $134 |
| | Dec 29 2017 | $280,000 | 155 | 2,167 sq ft | 98.3% | $129 |
| | Jun 2 2017 | $335,000 | 276 | 3,152 sq ft | 93.7% | $106 |
| | May 26 2017 | $316,250 | 28 | 3,024 sq ft | 98.8% | $105 |
| | May 25 2017 | $370,000 | 41 | 2,535 sq ft | 101.4% | $146 |
| | May 19 2017 | $237,500 | 43 | 1,845 sq ft | 101.1% | $129 |
| | Apr 17 2017 | $315,000 | 103 | 2,588 sq ft | 98.7% | $122 |
| | Aug 19 2016 | $195,500 | 99 | 1,729 sq ft | 98.2% | $113 |
| | Aug 16 2016 | $205,000 | 64 | 2,823 sq ft | 93.2% | $73 |
| | Aug 11 2016 | $200,000 | 105 | 1,890 sq ft | 93.0% | $106 |
| | Mar 4 2016 | $258,900 | 129 | 2,492 sq ft | 99.6% | $104 |
| | Aug 29 2014 | $255,000 | 137 | 2,952 sq ft | 98.1% | $86 |
| | Mar 27 2014 | $165,000 | 83 | 1,630 sq ft | 97.1% | $101 |
| | Mar 7 2014 | $21,500 | 107 | — | 71.9% | — |
| | Jan 30 2014 | $279,500 | 156 | 3,220 sq ft | 96.4% | $87 |
| | Apr 19 2013 | $148,000 | 100 | 2,244 sq ft | 99.4% | $66 |
| | Aug 31 2012 | $255,000 | 184 | 2,918 sq ft | 89.5% | $87 |
| | Aug 16 2012 | $240,000 | 261 | 2,436 sq ft | 96.2% | $99 |
| | Jun 29 2012 | $175,000 | 39 | 2,284 sq ft | 94.6% | $77 |
| | Apr 27 2012 | $205,000 | 200 | 1,863 sq ft | 93.2% | $110 |
Closed sales from MLS history for Indian Hill, Hendersonville
Indian Hill median sale price is $459,000; Hendersonville is down 1.3%.
The Indian Hill real estate market shows buyer's market conditions. Homes typically sell within 85 days. With 2 active listings and 4 homes sold in the past year, buyers have more negotiating power and time to decide.
Free account needed — create one to continue viewing homes.
Members see everything — free👋 Still browsing Indian Hill?
Full photos, price history, and every active & pending home in Indian Hill with a free account.
Palmetto Park Realty Team
$445K
$379KCheck your messages
We sent a code to .
Verify your number and we'll text you price drops and new Indian Hill listings. 1–2 texts a month, stop anytime.
Enjoy full access to this home and every home on Palmetto Park.