Nicholtown Homes for Sale
12 homeshistoric district
Community Highlights
- Steps from Swamp Rabbit Trail with multiple access points
- Walking distance to Cleveland Park, Greenville Zoo, and Holland Park
- Less than 2 miles to Downtown Greenville
- Active Nicholtown Neighborhood Association with Tool Lending Library and Community Garden
- Mix of renovated historic homes and new Craftsman construction
- No mandatory HOA with optional neighborhood association membership
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Tool Lending Library · Community Garden · Monthly meetings with City officials +1
steps from homes · Baxter Street · Sliding Rock Creek Trail
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Architecture & Style
- Open Floor Plans
- Hardwood Floors
- Granite Or Quartz Countertops
- Stainless Steel Appliances
- Covered Front Porches
- Main Level Primary Suite
- Fenced Backyards
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Location & Proximity
Historic in-town Greenville neighborhood
- Cleveland Park
- Greenville Zoo
- Holland Park
- Laurens Road shopping and dining
- Swamp Rabbit Trail
* Based on what we noticed in listing details.
Claudia Hinsdale
Operations Director & REALTOR®
Greenville
Questions about Nicholtown?
Call Us(864) 757-4000
Nicholtown stands out as one of Greenville's most walkable and rapidly evolving neighborhoods, where historic character meets modern urban living just minutes from Downtown.
Nicholtown stands out as one of Greenville's most walkable and rapidly evolving neighborhoods, where historic character meets modern urban living just minutes from Downtown. This historically significant community has emerged as a destination for buyers seeking authentic in-town living with direct access to the city's premier amenities.
Community Highlights
"Steps from the Swamp Rabbit Trail with Cleveland Park, Downtown Greenville, and Holland Park all within walking or biking distance"
Location defines Nicholtown's appeal. The community provides immediate access to the Swamp Rabbit Trail via multiple entry points, including the Baxter Street access and nearby Sliding Rock Creek Trail. Cleveland Park, the Greenville Zoo, and Holland Park sit within a comfortable walk, while Downtown Greenville's dining, entertainment, and cultural attractions are less than two miles away. Easy access to I-385 and Laurens Road adds commuting convenience without sacrificing the walkable lifestyle.
The neighborhood showcases a compelling mix of architectural periods. Historic homes from the 1940s-1960s have been thoughtfully renovated with modern kitchens featuring granite countertops, stainless appliances, and luxury vinyl plank flooring, while preserving original hardwood floors and character details. New construction from 2017-2025 introduces Craftsman-style homes with open floor plans, site-laid hardwood floors, 9-foot ceilings, main-level primary suites, and covered front porches that honor traditional neighborhood design principles.
These insights are based on listing details and are informational only; verify details for any specific property.
Market Trends
Fair conditions for both buyers and sellers. Room for negotiation. Prices have increased 68%. There's typically room for negotiation on price.
Year-over-Year Comparison
Last 12 months
Recently Sold Properties
| Property | Sold Date▼ | Sale Price↕ | DOM↕ | LP/SP↕ | Size↕ | $/SF↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 SOLD 226 Cowan Court 3 bed2 bath | Feb 6 2026 | $425,000 | 172 | 95% | 1523 sq ft | $279 |
 SOLD 6 Lark Street 2 bed1 bath | Jan 12 2026 | $155,000 | 32 | 89% | 764 sq ft | $203 |
 SOLD 16 Miller Street 3 bed1 bath | Jan 9 2026 | $270,000 | 110 | 93% | 848 sq ft | $318 |
 SOLD 31 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Jan 5 2026 | $409,000 | 51 | 🎯100% | 1693 sq ft | $242 |
 SOLD 12 Bridwell Avenue 3 bed2 bath | Dec 30 2025 | $425,000 | 93 | 94% | 1948 sq ft | $218 |
 SOLD 9 Virnelle Street 2 bed2 bath | Dec 5 2025 | $385,000 | 58 | 97% | 1207 sq ft | $319 |
 SOLD 109 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Nov 6 2025 | $430,000 | 33 | 🎯100% | 1657 sq ft | $260 |
 SOLD 108 Arden Street Extension 3 bed2 bath | Nov 4 2025 | $429,500 | 76 | 🎯100% | 1558 sq ft | $276 |
 SOLD 0 Palm Street | Oct 22 2025 | $240,000 | 206 | 🎯127% | — | — |
 SOLD 332 Ackley Road 3 bed2 bath | Aug 29 2025 | $407,500 | 50 | 🎯102% | 1400 sq ft | $291 |
 SOLD 8 Harris Lane 3 bed1 bath | Jul 28 2025 | $256,000 | 51 | 97% | 950 sq ft | $269 |
 SOLD 7 Hendricks Street 3 bed2 bath | Jul 11 2025 | $200,000 | 23 | 🎯100% | 1200 sq ft | $167 |
 SOLD 112 Arden St Extension 3 bed2 bath | Jun 16 2025 | $390,000 | 58 | 98% | 1227 sq ft | $318 |
 SOLD 6 Hendricks Street 4 bed3 bath | Jun 16 2025 | $625,000 | 73 | 🎯100% | 2500 sq ft | $250 |
 SOLD 14 Carter Street 3 bed1 bath | May 21 2025 | $315,000 | 41 | 95% | 1060 sq ft | $297 |
 SOLD 9 Merlocke Drive 3 bed2 bath | May 13 2025 | $429,000 | 80 | 🎯100% | 1443 sq ft | $297 |
 SOLD 23 Bridwell Avenue 3 bed1 bath | Apr 16 2025 | $253,000 | 47 | 92% | 1016 sq ft | $249 |
 SOLD 211 Ludlow Street 2 bed1 bath | Mar 25 2025 | $295,000 | 96 | 94% | 864 sq ft | $341 |
 SOLD 115 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Mar 13 2025 | $350,000 | 100 | 99% | 1430 sq ft | $245 |
 SOLD 4 Chaney Street 2 bed2 bath | Mar 13 2025 | $334,500 | 22 | 99% | 1314 sq ft | $255 |
 SOLD 320 Elder Street Extension 3 bed1 bath | Feb 28 2025 | $190,000 | 119 | 95% | 1225 sq ft | $155 |
 SOLD 30 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Feb 24 2025 | $416,000 | 50 | 🎯100% | 1747 sq ft | $238 |
 SOLD 119 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Feb 12 2025 | $360,000 | 60 | 98% | 1430 sq ft | $252 |
 SOLD 13 Miller Street 3 bed2 bath | Jan 17 2025 | $370,000 | 98 | 97% | 1332 sq ft | $278 |
 SOLD 2 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Dec 12 2024 | $390,000 | 42 | 99% | 1252 sq ft | $312 |
 SOLD 119 Maco Street | Nov 27 2024 | $175,000 | 67 | 88% | — | — |
 SOLD 15 Miller Street 3 bed2 bath | Nov 12 2024 | $393,700 | 51 | 🎯101% | 1382 sq ft | $285 |
 SOLD 101 Tuskegee Avenue 3 bed2 bath | Nov 8 2024 | $360,000 | 167 | 96% | 1097 sq ft | $328 |
 SOLD 10 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Oct 23 2024 | $398,000 | 32 | 🎯100% | 1702 sq ft | $234 |
 SOLD 14 Joseph Mathis Way 3 bed2 bath | Oct 22 2024 | $378,000 | 69 | 97% | 1554 sq ft | $243 |
226 Cowan Court
$425,000
6 Lark Street
$155,000
16 Miller Street
$270,000
31 Joseph Mathis Way
$409,000
12 Bridwell Avenue
$425,000
9 Virnelle Street
$385,000
109 Joseph Mathis Way
$430,000
108 Arden Street Extension
$429,500
0 Palm Street
$240,000
332 Ackley Road
$407,500
8 Harris Lane
$256,000
7 Hendricks Street
$200,000
112 Arden St Extension
$390,000
6 Hendricks Street
$625,000
14 Carter Street
$315,000
9 Merlocke Drive
$429,000
23 Bridwell Avenue
$253,000
211 Ludlow Street
$295,000
115 Joseph Mathis Way
$350,000
4 Chaney Street
$334,500
320 Elder Street Extension
$190,000
30 Joseph Mathis Way
$416,000
119 Joseph Mathis Way
$360,000
13 Miller Street
$370,000
2 Joseph Mathis Way
$390,000
119 Maco Street
$175,000
15 Miller Street
$393,700
101 Tuskegee Avenue
$360,000
10 Joseph Mathis Way
$398,000
14 Joseph Mathis Way
$378,000
Market Statistics
The Nicholtown real estate market shows balanced market conditions. Homes typically sell within 59 days. With 12 active listings and 20 homes sold in the past year, A healthy balance between buyers and sellers.
Pricing
Median Price:$394,950
Average Price:$421,508.25
Property Details
Avg Bedrooms:2.8
Avg Bathrooms:1.7
Avg Lot Size:0.18 acres
Market Activity
Active Listings:12
Sold Last Year:20
Median Days to Sell:59 days
Community Info
Has HOA:No
Median Year Built:2019
New Construction:3%
Recently Off Market Properties
11 propertiesLooking for similar properties?
These properties are no longer available, but we can help you find similar homes in Nicholtown. Our agents have access to upcoming listings and can notify you when new properties become available.